FireTeam K9 Dog Training

FireTeam K9 Dog Training

Home
Notes
Chat
YouTube
More Info
Podcast
Community
Archive
Leaderboard
About

Share this post

FireTeam K9 Dog Training
FireTeam K9 Dog Training
Stop Calling Your Dog a “Rescue”

Stop Calling Your Dog a “Rescue”

Labels can comfort us—but sometimes, they keep our dogs stuck...

Karl Anthony 🇨🇦's avatar
Karl Anthony 🇨🇦
Jun 20, 2025
13

Share this post

FireTeam K9 Dog Training
FireTeam K9 Dog Training
Stop Calling Your Dog a “Rescue”
16
4
Share
Cross-post from FireTeam K9 Dog Training
This week, Dog Snobs is featuring a cross-post written by Karl Anthony. The topic is fantastic and conjured up a real mixed bag of feelings in me, mostly because I saw myself and my dog in bits of it. Also, if you know me you know I'm never one to shy away from a controversial topic or two 😁 Enjoy this read and PLEASE, if you have two cents, drop them in the comments. I can't wait for the responses. -
Kristi Keller 🇨🇦
woman in blue and white floral shirt lying on red sofa
Photo by Jeremy Stewardson on Unsplash

There’s a trend I’ve noticed in the dog world that’s become so common, so quietly accepted, that we rarely question it anymore.

It sounds like this:

“Oh, she’s a rescue.”
“He has issues; he was rescued.”
“She’s reactive, but it’s not her fault. She’s a rescue.”

Sometimes this label is said with pride. Other times, with an apologetic tone. But either way, the subtext is the same:

“This dog has a past. And I need you to know that before you judge what you see.”

I get it. I do. Many dogs end up in shelters because of human failure, neglect, poor training, impulse purchases, or major life shifts. And when we take in a dog that’s been through something difficult, there’s a natural pull to acknowledge it. To honour their story. To explain their quirks.

But here’s the uncomfortable truth: clinging to the “rescue” label can keep your dog from healing, growing, and stepping into who they’re best self.

Let me explain.


Your Dog Is Not Their Origin Story

I’ve met people who adopted their dog from a shelter at 8 weeks old, and still refer to that dog, six years later, as a rescue.

I’ve seen dogs that were surrendered simply because a family moved into an apartment and had to give up their dog. No abuse. No trauma. Just logistics. But now they carry a label that paints them as damaged goods.

And then there are the stories that feel more like fiction.
A shelter influencer once told me about someone who adopted a dog, took hundreds of photos and hours of videos in different outfits and locations, and returned the dog the next day. Three months of “content” built off a fake rescue narrative, for likes, engagement, and brand alignment.

We’ve created a culture where “rescue dog” can be a badge of honour, or worse, a tool for social currency. But at what cost?


The Problem With Labels

Labels are powerful. They give us language, context, even comfort. But they also limit us.

When we keep calling our dog a “rescue,” we can unintentionally:

  • Excuse or overlook problematic behaviour

  • Assume trauma that was never there

  • Project our guilt, saviour complex, or need for purpose onto the dog

  • Ignore the progress they’ve made

  • Delay training, clarity, and leadership in the name of compassion

And perhaps most importantly:
We define them by what may have happened to them, rather than who they are now.

That’s not freedom. That’s a soft cage. And it’s hurting the dogs.


From Rescue to Relationship

When I brought Piper home, she was one year old. She had a lot of intensity, very little foundation, and more drive than she knew what to do with. In some ways, sure, she needed to be “rescued” from a situation that wasn’t right for her.

But I don’t introduce her as my “rescue.”
I introduce her as my dog.

She’s 4.5 years old now. She’s calm in the house. She’s reliable off-leash. She can work in public, play with drive, settle with ease, and hold eye contact when I need her to. She’s my training partner, my hiking buddy, my mirror. My FireTeam Partner.

She’s not her past. She’s who we’ve built together.

And that’s the story I want to tell.


Are You Keeping Your Dog Stuck?

This post might ruffle a few feathers. And that’s okay. Growth often does.

But here’s what I invite you to consider:

  • Is your dog still wearing a label that no longer fits?

  • Are you unintentionally holding them back by excusing behaviour instead of training through it?

  • Have you done the hard, beautiful work of building something new, or are you still reliving the old story?

What if we stopped saying “rescue” like it’s a permanent identity, and started saying, “This is my dog. Here’s what we’ve accomplished together.”?

What if we chose progress over pity?

What if we led our dogs into freedom by treating them like dogs, not babies, not broken projects, not social media props, but companions worthy of our respect, guidance, and trust?


The Spiritual Side

I can’t help but see the parallel in our own lives.
We all carry stories, some painful, some unfair, some full of loss. But healing begins when we stop letting our past define us and start choosing who we want to become.

Our dogs deserve the same grace.

To be seen for who they are.
To be led with clarity.
To be loved for more than their origin story.


Join the Conversation

What’s your take on the “rescue” label?
Has it helped your relationship with your dog, or held them back?
Drop a comment. Let’s talk about it, honestly.

Leave a comment


Next Steps

If this post resonated with you, you’ll love the upcoming current lessons in my How Dogs Learn series.
We’re going deep into what shapes behaviour, and how to train the dog in front of you, with clarity, structure, and compassion.

Want more support?
Join the FireTeam K9 paid community for training videos, group coaching, and real-time feedback as you grow your relationship with your dog.

User's avatar
Join Karl Anthony 🇨🇦’s subscriber chat
Available in the Substack app and on web

No labels. Just leadership.
Let’s train.

- Karl Anthony
FireTeam K9 Coach/Trainer
Edmonton, AB, Canada

13

Share this post

FireTeam K9 Dog Training
FireTeam K9 Dog Training
Stop Calling Your Dog a “Rescue”
16
4
Share

No posts

© 2025 Karl MacPhee
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share